
I just finished reading
The
Hunger Games trilogy for the first time. And for the past week I have had hundreds
of thoughts swirling around in my head as strong emotions churn throughout me. Needless
to say, Suzanne Collins is a powerful writer.
If you have not read the trilogy, you should go find a
summary online since the rest of this post won’t make sense if you don’t know
the story. There are quite a few opposing opinions on this series in Christian
circles: Is it merely an exciting story
full of gore, or is there anything redemptive? What about the violence?
Today I simply want to offer some of my insights and reflections. And…I will be
the first to admit that my reading of The
Hunger Games is colored by my worldview. So with that in mind, here we go.
WARNING: Spoilers abound.
Throughout the series, we journey with Katniss as she
struggles to separate her feelings for 2 important boys in her life: Gale and
Peeta. In the end, she chooses Peeta because she realizes that “…what I need to
survive is not Gale’s fire, kindled with rage and hatred. I have plenty of fire
myself. What I need is the dandelion in the spring. The bright yellow that
means rebirth instead of destruction. The promise the life can go on, no matter
how bad our losses. That it can be good again. And only Peeta can give me
that.” (
Mockingjay, 388) Read an
excellent article on this very topic
here.
I think that there is a part of every girl that longs for
someone like Peeta in their life – solid, sacrificial, loving, life-giving. As
I contemplated, I realized…I DO have that already in my life! And no, I’m not
talking about Jonathan (though I love him dearly and am VERY thankful for
him!). I have Jesus Christ.
HE is the Bread of Life. He is my solid foundation. He is the Lover of my soul.
He gave His life for mine! Though it is probably not the author’s intention
(and maybe I’m reading too much into it), I can’t help but think that in many
ways, Peeta acts as a Christ-like figure in the trilogy. Think about it:
Peeta is a baker’s son and once saved Katniss’s life by
throwing her bread.
Christ is my Bread of Life.
Peeta loves Katniss unconditionally, even when she doesn’t
love him back.
Christ loves me unconditionally, even when I am unfaithful
to Him.
Peeta
experiences the Games with Katniss and is able to empathize because he knows
exactly what she’s been through.
Christ
empathizes with us because He was fully man and has been tempted in every way
that we have. (Heb. 4:15)
Peeta calms and comforts Katniss during her nightmares.
In the same way, Christ wraps His arms around me and calms
my fears.
Peeta is the groom. Katniss is the bride.
Christ is my Groom. I am His bride.
Peeta represents life and goodness and hope.
Christ IS life. He is the Giver of good things. He is Hope.
And the biggest of all:
Peeta is
willing to sacrifice his life to save Katniss’s life. Katniss talks a lot about
“owing” those around her, especially Peeta.
Jesus Christ actually
gave His life for mine. Do I not owe
him my life?
Of course, Peeta is only human, so the analogy breaks down
after awhile. But you get the idea.
In the books, we are forced to confront the hopeless reality
of human depravity. In
Mockingjay, Katniss
– the heroine and antagonist – even recognizes it in herself: she describes
herself as “Violent. Distrustful. Manipulative. Deadly.” (232). In the end, it
comes as no surprise (to me) that she votes “yes” to a Games using tributes
from the Capitol. Or that she kills President Coin. Or that she is driven to
the point of suicide. Because ultimately, her actions mirror my own deadly,
avenging heart. As part of our human nature, we long to repay death with death,
an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth. But Christ has a better way – outlined in
Matthew
5:38-48.
Maybe it’s just me and I’m too sensitive to pain and loss,
but I was overcome by a sense of darkness and despair that I couldn’t shake
after finishing the series. I wept the night that I finished the 3rd
book because of the enormity of hopelessness and darkness that I felt. While
the ending of the series was as “happy” as it could have been without Christ, I
still longed for so much more!
“I long for that comfort of the Redeemer. There seems
to be no hope in the [Hunger Games] that things will be made right, only that
eventually, the nightmares may get better. Having the comfort of redemption and
hope, I can’t help but wish for that in the world of Panem–a Redeemer to come
and wash away the tears. And so, because there is no such Redeemer, I see the
stories as a reflection of the brutal reality of a world without God. In such a
world the best that can be hoped for is that the nightmares may one day end;
that children may have a better life than their parents. But ultimately, it is
a hard reality, one in which there is no true hope, no way to atone for past
wrongs.”
Ultimately, Collins is successful in setting up the problem
without giving us the solution. I think The
Hunger Games is an excellent catalyst for discussion; however, I would not
recommend this for younger readers. The books are violent and dark. I am old-fashioned – I don't think it is appropriate for middleschoolers or
even highschoolers necessarily unless there is someone who can talk through the
complex moral and ethical issues that the author deals with throughout the
story. You could see it as a commentary on poverty, war, government, where
our society is headed…but ultimately, Collins dives into the depths of what
really makes us human – what is it that makes us more than animals? Anything? What
is love? What is sacrifice? What is the proper response to death and violence?
Where do we find hope?
There is so much more I could write about, but I would
probably just be repeating what has already been said. Instead, you should just
read the articles that are linked throughout this post (and here’s
one
more on Christian themes found in the trilogy). Many of them were
influential in my thinking as I tried to sort out my thoughts.
For those of you who are wondering, I do think that this is
a worthy read (I only speak for the books, not the movie since I haven’t seen
it). Might I suggest that if you do decide to read them (or already have), read
them more than once. The first time you’ll just be so caught up in the story
that your mind won’t really dwell on the deeper issues presented.
Finally, I came across this just today:
What do you think? Do you agree with Sheldon, or do you
think that in order to truly appreciate our salvation we should delve into the
depths of sinful humanity? Is reading something like The Hunger Games unnecessary because we already see so much of human
depravity in real life and we should dwell on “whatever is true, whatever is
noble, whatever is right, etc.” (Phil. 4:8)? No doubt, the books are dark. But
is there enough eye-opening truth in the books that makes it redemptive
reading? You tell me. I welcome your thoughts.